While we celebrate potatoes fried in oil to remind us of the miracle, the original latke may have been more of a homage to The Book of Judith. The first documented latke is mentioned in the 13th century by Italian Rabbi Kalonymus ben Kalonymus in a poem about pancakes for Hanukkah. But why cheese? For those unfamiliar with the story, The Book of Judith is an apocryphal work that tells the story of a heroic woman who saves the Jews from the Assyrians.
Judith lived in the town of Bethulia during the sixth century B.C. The story’s drama begins as the town is under siege and surrounded by enemies. The Jews close to defeat, are discussing surrendering unless God can save them. Frustrated by the lack of faith of her fellow villagers, Judith takes action and creates a plan to befriend the enemy’s leader, Holofernes, a general for Nebuchadnezzar, King of the Assyrians.
The general, taken in by Judith’s beauty invites her to his table. The pair continue to see each other over a few days and once again Judith is invited to a banquet in his tent. During the festive meal, Judith continues to feed him a steady helping of a salty cheese dish, driving his thirst. Throughout the evening, he continues to drink wine to quench his thirst and passes out drunk on his bed. As everyone else has left the tent, Judith takes the opportunity to grab his sword and cut off his head.
She takes his head back to the town of Bethulia and declares God’s glory. The Israelis, then attack forcing the Assyrians to flee.
While the story of Judith takes place hundreds of years prior to the Hanukkah miracle, the story was often conflated with Hannukah and read on the Shabbat before or during the holiday. In her honor, generations have eaten dairy foods to celebrate the victory. Combine cheese and oil and we get the first latke! It wasn’t until the 19th century that potatoes took center stage.